Prepare for the MCAT with our comprehensive study tools. Access flashcards and multiple-choice questions, complete with hints and explanations. Get ready to achieve your medical school dreams!

Individuals produce more lactic acid primarily during anaerobic respiration, which occurs when there is insufficient oxygen available for aerobic metabolism. This is more likely to happen during intense exercise or physical activity, particularly in individuals who are not well-conditioned.

In less-conditioned individuals, the body has lower efficiency in using oxygen, which means that, during high-intensity activities or when the muscles are pushed beyond their aerobic capacity, the body resorts to anaerobic metabolism to meet energy demands. This process leads to the production and accumulation of lactic acid in the muscles, resulting in the familiar burning sensation and fatigue.

On the other hand, well-conditioned or fit individuals tend to have a higher capacity for aerobic metabolism due to adaptations from training. They can sustain higher intensities of exercise while relying more on aerobic pathways, thereby limiting the production of lactic acid. Being in shape or at rest typically means better oxygen availability and use, further reducing lactic acid production. Hence, increased lactic acid production is most characteristic of individuals who are not in shape, particularly when subjected to strenuous activity.